Couples/Relationship Therapy
4
min read
WHAT IF I WANT TO WORK ON THE MARRIAGE BUT MY SPOUSE DOESN’T?
By Caralee Hammer Frederic, LCSW, CGT

If you want to work on the marriage but your spouse has voiced indifference, ambivalence, or a lack of desire, what can you do?
Historically, people have been counseled to either go to therapy alone - endorsed by Ann Landers back in the day - or to try to persuade their partner to go for “one session” or to “give it one last shot”. Neither of these options has actually proven very beneficial.
It is a well known phenomenon that individual therapy very often undermines marriage. There are significantly more individual therapists than trained marriage therapists. Without a good understanding the dynamics of working with a couple on their relationship, individual therapists often give counsel or advice that is good for the individual but not for the marriage. An argument can be made for the value of a person gaining clarity and insight about needing to leave a marriage, but that is an individual goal, not a couples goal. As a marriage therapist, I am always relieved to consult with individual therapists who have some training and understanding of relational dynamics and who can support the couples’ work I’m doing. Unfortunately, this is hard to find. More often, we are at cross purposes.
The other option - persuade or brow beat your partner to going to marriage counseling “one time” or as a “last attempt”, sets up a losing dynamic. The partner who is ambivalent has a valid part of not wanting to be there. But with this request, they can either concede - often half heartedly - or resist. Since we all want to look “reasonable, good and cooperative” to some degree, if this couple shows up in my office, there is a lot of hidden resistance to the process of marriage therapy to protect the part that doesn’t want to be there in first place.
A third, newer option is available that didn’t exist before. Discernment Counseling is a brief couples process - between 1-5 sessions - that is designed to help couples talk about their thoughts, feelings and desires - especially ambivalence and doubt - honestly. This is facilitated by meeting for the bulk of the session 1:1 with the Discernment Counselor. Each partner is challenged to go deeper, explore, analyze and feel the truth of their own reality. At the beginning and end and at the transition point, both partners meet with the therapist and articulate in front of each other what path they’re on currently - staying without significant change, divorcing or investing whole heartedly into making meaningful changes - and a brief summary of what they are focusing on in the process. The couple is only asked to commit to one discernment session at a time, so that the partner who is ambivalent can freely choose whether to continue the process or not.
Pressuring a person to move in a direction they don’t want to is not only ineffective, but disrespectful and possibly abusive. I urge my couples to accept their own timing and process and that of their partner fully. A decision as important as whether to stay in a marriage or not should be made carefully, with consideration, patience and honesty. This is a process that cannot be rushed, despite the difficulty of sitting with the uncertainty.
If you’re the partner who wants to do anything to save the marriage, say so, and then consider what “All in” would require of you and the information your partner has given you about what it’s like to be married to you. What do you legitimately need to work on to be a better version of you? A better partner? What are you willing to work on?
If you’re the partner who is considering leaving, say so, and then consider carefully all the factors that brought you to this point, including your own part, what would need to happen for you to consider the possibility of opening the door to working on the relationship and what that would require of you as well as your partner.
Both need to also honestly think about and challenge assumptions and fantasies - both positive and negative - of what divorcing would look like on the other side. Who else besides you will be affected. Have you considered as many possible outcomes as possible?
And if neither the path of divorce nor an “all in effort” can be decided right now, be content with being on an “As Is” path, where neither one is leaving, but neither is working to improve the marriage as the default option.
