Couples/Relationship Therapy
5
min read
DO WE NEED DISCERNMENT COUNSELING OR MARRIAGE THERAPY?
By Caralee Hammer Frederic, LCSW, CGT

You’re in distress and so is your partner. It’s been too hard for too long. Or maybe you’re in an unexpected crisis.
One or both of you may have confided in a friend, close family member or clergy for help to know what to do next.
How do we make this pain stop? How do we get reconnected? Do I even want to connect anymore?
You are likely even to have reached out to AI in its various forms and asked a number of questions from an “impartial source”. In this day, you are aware that marriage therapy is a viable option. What is that all about? In your search, you stumbled upon this thing called Discernment Counseling for “mixed agenda couples” or ambivalence. How do you know which one would be better for you? Like most people, you’re likely to have have limited time, energy and money, so the decision feels pressing.
As a very experienced therapist with over 2 decades specializing in couples’ work as a Certified Gottman therapist and Certified in Discernment Counseling, I assess all new couples for ambivalence and which is the better fit.
In order to be effective in marriage therapy, both partners need to be whole heartedly interested in making this relationship work and being a better version of themselves. There needs to be a desire to grow psychologically, to see and feel new and uncomfortable things about oneself and the relationship and, an ability and willingness to change for the sake of becoming one’s best self and to create a healthier, happier relationship for both.
To whatever degree “whole heartedly” sounds like too much to ask, ambivalence is present. Ambivalence is defined as “having simultaneous conflicting or mixed feelings”; uncertainty, unable to decide on a course of action. Ambivalence is “partially committed” - part of me wants to, part of me doesn’t. It’s “iffy” on whether or not to do this hard work. It’s split on wanting to get a divorce or not. Ambivalence shows up as doubt, second guessing, anguish, confusion, starting and stopping a course of action. It’s a difficult and very painful place to be.
When I meet with a new couple and listen to their concerns, I am listening for what either might describe as Leaning In and Leaning Out behaviors. Some of the clearest indicators that one or both partners is Leaning Out include and intentions, actions or expressions opening the door to divorce.
These include:
Frequent thoughts of leaving or divorcing.
Conversations between the couple about divorce.
Threats to leave or divorce.
Conversations with friends, family, clergy about marital complaints or leaving.
Separating - living space or in home
Any kind of infidelity - current, recent or past.
Secrets or withholding information from the partner.
Actions to protect self, e.g. setting up separate bank accounts, sleeping separately, consulting with an attorney
Feeling marriage or family is a burden and wanting relief.
Viewing divorce as a path to freedom and a new life.
Comparing their current life, marriage, or spouse to an ideal other.
Fantasies about what post divorce life will look like without in depth consideration.
Unwillingness or inability to turn towards their partner’s requests for change or connection.
When there are Leaning Out behaviors or thoughts, it makes sense to create a space where the ambivalence can be fully acknowledged and worked with. Discernment Counseling was designed specifically for this purpose. Prior to Discernment Counseling, there were few ways to tackle the ambivalence head on. It felt threatening and scary to openly admit doubts, desires and fears clearly, especially in front of one’s spouse. However, ambivalence is so powerful, it can hinder any and all progress towards change. I saw couples spend a long time in therapy making very slow and minimal progress due to the uncertainty of whether or not they really wanted to be here, doing the work.
The design of Discernment Counseling is unique from marriage therapy, in that the bulk of each session is split between each partner and the therapist, meeting one on one. The couple attend together to check in on the goals and paths of Discernment and then each one has individual time with the therapist to delve deeply into how they see their options of staying to work “whole heartedly” on the marriage, leaving/divorcing or staying but without meaningful changes. Each partner has the space to speak freely and honestly about their view and understanding of what’s happened in the marriage to get to this point and to explore their own contributions and what s/he would need to change to create a better marriage. Without the other partner in the room, there is no concern about hurting feelings or picking fights. Each partner has the opportunity to summarize their main takeaway from the 1:1 time, giving their partner a small indication of what they are continuing to discern.
Each partner is challenged in their individual time to discern, in the service of finding clarity. To Discern means to recognize, perceive or understand something clearly, especially when it is hidden, subtle, or difficult to see, through careful thought and consideration. It requires increasing insight and good judgment. For all of us, it is difficult to see ourselves clearly. Engaging with a Certified Discernment Counselor in this process is a wise way to clear the debris of confusion and to create clarity and confidence moving forward - whichever path is chosen.
